How do you get off exchange health insurance plans in Illinois?

Ready to explore off-exchange PPO options for your Illinois small business?

If you’re tired of limited networks, rising premiums, and confusing Marketplace choices, you don’t have to navigate this alone.

My Private Health Insurance can help you:

• See whether your business is a good candidate for an underwritten off-exchange PPO

• Compare private PPO plans against your current coverage

• Design a benefits package that supports your employees and respects your bottom line

Next step:
Reach out for a free, no-obligation quote and let’s see what off-exchange PPO options are available for your Illinois small business.

If you’re a small business owner in Illinois, you’ve probably noticed something: the ACA marketplace options for group coverage can feel limited, expensive, and confusing. Maybe you’ve tried shopping on Healthcare.gov or through a local broker and found mostly HMO or narrow-network options, with high deductibles that still leave your team paying a lot out of pocket.

That’s where off-exchange PPO plans come in.

These are private, non-Marketplace plans that can give your Illinois small business broader networks, more flexible benefits, and—if your group is relatively healthy—potentially lower overall costs compared to “full price” ACA-compliant plans (especially when you’re not qualifying for heavy tax credits).

In this article, we’ll walk through what off-exchange PPO plans are, how they work in Illinois, and the steps to get them for your small business.

---

What is an off-exchange PPO plan?

Off-exchange simply means the plan is not purchased through the federal ACA Marketplace (HealthCare.gov). Instead, it’s sold directly by private insurance carriers or through licensed brokers. These plans still have to follow certain state and federal rules, but they’re marketed and underwritten outside the exchange.

A PPO (Preferred Provider Organization) plan typically offers:

• A broader network of doctors and hospitals

• The ability to see specialists without referrals

• Out-of-network coverage (usually at a higher cost-sharing)

• More flexibility for employees who travel or have preferred providers

In Illinois, small employers (usually defined as 1–50 employees in the small-group market) can access both on-exchange ACA small-group plans and off-exchange plans sold directly by carriers or via brokers. Some of these are PPO options, some are HMO or EPO. The key is knowing how to shop beyond the Marketplace.

---

Why small businesses in Illinois look for off-exchange PPO options

Illinois small business owners often start looking for off-exchange PPO plans because of one or more of these issues:

1. Network frustration

Marketplace and some HMO/EPO plans can limit which hospitals and specialists are “in network.” That can be a big problem if:

• Your employees already have established doctors

• You want access to specific health systems (like large university hospitals or specialty centers)

• Staff travel between cities or out of state

A PPO design can give more freedom for employees to choose where they get care.

2. Rising premiums and deductibles

Even when you choose a metal tier like Silver or Gold, you might find:

• Premiums feel high for what you’re getting

• Deductibles and out-of-pocket maximums are still painful

• You’re paying more each year without seeing better benefits

Off-exchange PPO options sometimes allow more creative plan design, cost-sharing, and employer contributions—especially when you work with a broker who focuses on private alternatives for small groups.

3. You don’t qualify for big tax credits

Individual employees might get ACA subsidies on the exchange, but small businesses themselves typically use a different tax credit structure (the Small Business Health Care Tax Credit), and many employers don’t qualify or find it limited. When that’s the case, your cost comparison shifts: off-exchange PPO plans can become more competitive versus “full price” ACA plans without big subsidies attached.

---

How off-exchange PPO plans work for small businesses in Illinois

While every carrier and plan type is different, most private off-exchange PPO plans for small business owners share a few traits:

1. They’re often underwritten

Many off-exchange PPOs for small groups aren’t “guaranteed issue” in the same way as ACA-compliant community-rated plans. Instead, they may:

• Look at your group’s overall health profile

• Ask basic health questions on applications

• Use that information to accept, decline, or rate your group

The advantage: when your employees (and their dependents) are relatively healthy, underwriting can sometimes lead to significantly lower premiums compared to ACA small-group plans priced for everyone, including higher-risk populations.

The tradeoff: if several employees have major ongoing conditions, you may not qualify for some of these off-exchange options, or the pricing might not be as favorable.

2. They may have more flexible benefit design

Off-exchange PPOs can offer:

• Different deductible structures (sometimes lower than standard ACA plans)

• More generous office visit copays

• Better out-of-network reimbursements

• Options to add supplemental benefits (dental, vision, accident, critical illness)

Depending on the carrier and structure (level-funded, partially self-funded, or fully insured), you might also see options for shared savings when claims are lower than expected.

3. They still provide real coverage

Legitimate off-exchange PPO plans for employers are not discount cards or flimsy “health sharing” arrangements. They:

• Issue real insurance ID cards

• Pay claims through a recognized carrier or TPA

• Give you access to a PPO network with negotiated rates

• Include key protections detailed in your plan documents

The important part is to work with a licensed advisor who can clearly show you who the carrier is, what network is being used, and what is and isn’t covered.

---

Steps to get off-exchange PPO plans for your Illinois small business

If you’re in Illinois and you want to explore off-exchange PPO options for your company, here’s a straightforward path to follow.

Step 1: Clarify your group size and business structure

Most small-group and underwritten off-exchange PPO programs are aimed at 1–50 employee businesses. Some options may require:

• At least one W-2 employee besides the owner, OR

• A husband-and-wife team working together, OR

• A certain percentage of employees enrolling (participation requirement)

Before shopping, make sure you can provide:

• Your legal business name and structure (LLC, S-Corp, etc.)

• Your employee count (full-time equivalents)

• Basic information on who you want to cover (owners only, owners + staff, full family coverage, etc.)

Step 2: Gather employee census information

To get accurate quotes for off-exchange PPO plans, you’ll need a simple census that includes, for each enrollee:

• Name (or initials/ID, depending on your broker’s process)

• Date of birth

• ZIP code (Illinois business ZIP and sometimes home ZIPs if remote)

• Relationship (employee, spouse, dependent)

• Tobacco status (in many cases)

This census lets carriers or underwriting programs evaluate risk and pricing. It’s standard for group health coverage—both ACA and off-exchange.

Step 3: Decide your budget and goals

Before you look at plan designs, think through:

• Monthly budget: What can your business comfortably contribute per employee?

• Employee cost-sharing: How much of the premium do you want employees to pay vs. the company?

• Benefits priorities:

  • Lower deductible vs. lower monthly premium

  • Access to specific hospital systems

  • Strong out-of-network coverage for traveling staff

  • Copays for primary care and specialist visits

Having this in mind helps a broker or advisor narrow down which off-exchange PPO options are realistic for you.

Step 4: Work with a licensed advisor who understands Illinois private PPO options

This is the key step.

Not every broker actively works with underwritten off-exchange PPO solutions. Many only quote standard ACA small-group plans. When you talk to an advisor (like us at My Private Health Insurance), ask specifically for:

• Off-exchange PPO options

• Any underwritten or level-funded small-group PPO plans you might qualify for

• A clear explanation of how underwriting works, what information is needed, and what approval looks like

A good advisor will:

• Shop multiple carriers or programs

• Explain Illinois-specific rules that apply to your business size

• Compare ACA small-group premiums vs. off-exchange PPO pricing

• Show you side-by-side plan summaries so you can see deductibles, copays, and network differences clearly

Step 5: Complete the applications and underwriting

Once you’ve chosen an off-exchange PPO option that looks like a good fit:

1. Employees complete health questionnaires, if required.

2. The carrier reviews the group’s overall health information.

3. You receive:

   • Final rates

   • Acceptance terms (or occasionally, a decline or requested modification)

If the final offer makes sense, you sign the employer application and set your effective date. Many small groups can start coverage on the 1st of any month—you don’t always have to wait for traditional “open enrollment” the way individuals do on the ACA Marketplace.

Step 6: Set up payroll deductions and onboard your team

After approval:

• Your advisor should help you structure employer vs. employee contributions.

• You’ll arrange payroll deductions so employees can pay their share pre-tax when possible (often through a Section 125/cafeteria plan that your payroll provider or benefits administrator can help set up).

• Your team receives ID cards and can register online with the carrier to find in-network providers, pharmacies, and claims info.

---

Benefits of choosing an off-exchange PPO for your Illinois small business

When you qualify and the numbers make sense, off-exchange PPO plans can give your business some strong advantages:

1. Potential cost savings

Because underwriting can reward healthier groups, it’s possible to see:

• Lower monthly premiums than many ACA small-group options at similar benefit levels

• Better “value per dollar” in terms of deductibles and copays

• More predictable costs if you choose well-designed level-funded options

2. Stronger provider access

For many Illinois employees, provider choice matters. PPO networks can:

• Offer more hospitals and specialists

• Provide out-of-network benefits when your employees travel

• Reduce the frustration of having to change doctors just because the plan changed

3. Happier, more competitive benefits for recruiting and retention

In a tight labor market, offering solid PPO coverage instead of “bare minimum” plans can:

• Make your job offers more attractive

• Help you keep experienced employees

• Show your team that you genuinely care about their health and their families

---

Things to watch out for

Off-exchange PPO plans aren’t a free-for-all. A few important cautions:

• Underwriting means not everyone qualifies. If your group has several major ongoing conditions, ACA community-rated plans may be the better or only option.

• Plan details matter. Look closely at deductibles, out-of-pocket maximums, drug coverage, and out-of-network rules—don’t assume all PPOs are the same.

• Avoid anything that isn’t true insurance. Be careful with “plans” that are only discount cards, health-sharing ministries, or limited-benefit products presented as full coverage. Your advisor should be able to clearly name the insurance company, PPO network, and policy type.

---

How My Private Health Insurance can help Illinois small businesses

At My Private Health Insurance, we specialize in helping small employers—especially those who don’t qualify for big ACA subsidies—find off-exchange PPO alternatives that fit real budgets and real needs.

For Illinois small businesses, we can:

• Review your current coverage and costs

• Build a census and shop underwritten PPO options where appropriate

• Compare ACA small-group plans vs. private PPO solutions

• Walk you through underwriting step-by-step

• Help you implement the plan, set contributions, and support your employees at enrollment

---

Ready to explore off-exchange PPO options for your Illinois small business?

If you’re tired of limited networks, rising premiums, and confusing Marketplace choices, you don’t have to navigate this alone.

My Private Health Insurance can help you:

• See whether your business is a good candidate for an underwritten off-exchange PPO

• Compare private PPO plans against your current coverage

• Design a benefits package that supports your employees and respects your bottom line

Next step:
Reach out for a free, no-obligation quote and let’s see what off-exchange PPO options are available for your Illinois small business.